WINDOW SWITCHER COMPARISON

Witch vs StillSwitch: Custom Switching or a Fixed Routine?

Build a switching system around your habits, or use one already decided.

Written by the maker of StillSwitch. Official sources checked . This comparison covers documented features, not hands-on benchmarks. Offers and compatibility can change.

How much control do you want over switching?

Witch is worth considering if you want several configurable switchers, detailed ordering choices or supported app tabs in the list. StillSwitch is designed for people who prefer one consistent Cmd+Tab interaction for individual windows. It trades that configurability for fewer decisions before and during everyday use.

Witch can adapt to several ways of working.

Witch supports app, window and supported-tab switching, with horizontal, vertical and menu-bar presentations. Its configuration covers multiple switcher actions, ordering, search, exclusions and appearance.

The official help documents a working Option+Tab default, so you do not have to configure everything before using it. It also describes on-demand window previews with P or Space. Witch is not simply a text-only list.

Tab support is a meaningful difference.

Witch can reach inside some app windows to select tabs. Its supported-app guidance explains that this depends on compatible app behavior; it is not a promise about every tab in every app.

StillSwitch stops at the window boundary. A browser window with several related tabs is one destination. This keeps the switching list focused on the workspaces you have opened, but it does not replace tab search. If individual tabs are what you repeatedly lose, Witch’s approach may solve more of your problem.

StillSwitch makes the design decisions once.

There is one fixed presentation, individual-window recency and the familiar Cmd+Tab gesture. Separate windows of the same app remain separate choices. Previews help distinguish a project window from a reference window without first choosing their shared application.

No layout selector, theme editor or alternate switcher configurations need your attention. You grant macOS permissions, learn the small routine and use it. Zero configuration is not a promise to remove permission or license steps; it is a commitment to keeping the switching experience settled.

A brief interaction deserves careful preparation.

StillSwitch prepares the window list and layout ahead of the shortcut, refreshes preview images independently and adds no switching animation. It focuses its work on the transition from selecting a window to using it.

These are documented implementation priorities, not evidence that Witch is slower. A useful comparison is whether your own repeated switches feel predictable, and whether the options you gain are options you actually want.

Compatibility and updates are different.

Witch’s product page lists version 4.7 for macOS 10.13 or later, a US$14 new license and a free trial. Its license remains valid indefinitely and includes at least one year of updates. Check the publisher’s current terms before buying.

StillSwitch requires Apple Silicon and macOS 15 or later. It includes 14 days free, then a US$19.99 StillSwitch 1.x license for up to three Macs. That license includes 1.x updates; it does not promise every future major version. See the full trial and license explanation.

Make the decision around your working day.

Choose Witch if multiple switching modes, tab access or detailed controls are useful to you. Try StillSwitch if you would rather leave those choices to the product and get back to your windows.

Compare them separately with the same everyday tasks. Switch between a browser window, a document and another window of the same app. Include your usual displays and Spaces. The best fit is the routine you want to keep using after the comparison is over.

Download for Mac StillSwitch setup, trial & requirements

StillSwitch: 14 days free, then a paid license. No card for the trial. Apple Silicon and macOS 15 or later.