DockDoor vs StillSwitch: Dock Previews or Focused Cmd+Tab?
A richer Dock experience, or a dedicated window-switching routine.
Written by the maker of StillSwitch. Official sources checked . This comparison covers documented features, not hands-on benchmarks. Offers and compatibility can change.
Do you work from the Dock or from Cmd+Tab?
DockDoor is a strong candidate if you want previews when hovering over Dock icons, alongside a configurable keyboard switcher. StillSwitch concentrates on individual-window switching through Cmd+Tab. It is designed for the moment you want to leave one window and resume work in another, with the interaction already decided.
DockDoor extends an existing place to look.
DockDoor adds window previews to the macOS Dock and includes an Option+Tab keyboard switcher. It offers customization, search and other optional window controls. It is not limited to mouse-based navigation.
The free app is open source under GPLv3 and supports Intel and Apple Silicon Macs on macOS 13 or later. DockDoor Pro is a separate Dock replacement; it should not be confused with the free utility that enhances the built-in Dock.
Think about where a switch begins.
When you already have your pointer near a Dock icon, seeing that app’s windows there can be convenient. If you frequently alternate between typing in a document and checking another window, a keyboard-first routine may fit more naturally.
StillSwitch puts eligible windows from different apps into a single recent-use list. Two browser windows are two destinations. You do not select the browser first and then decide which of its windows you intended. Hold Command, move with Tab or Shift+Tab, and release Command on your choice.
DockDoor also offers keyboard switching. The reason to choose StillSwitch is therefore not exclusive access to keyboard navigation; it is the deliberate limits around that interaction.
A switcher that stays a switcher.
StillSwitch does not add Dock widgets, sidebar organization or a layout editor. Its interface is fixed, with no theme selection or switching animation. You can spend your attention on recognizing the window, rather than maintaining a customized workspace tool.
DockDoor’s automation documentation also describes AppleScript access to previews, switching and window actions. That may matter if you build workflows around macro buttons or scripts. StillSwitch is aimed at a different need: a useful default routine that does not ask you to build a workflow around it.
Small scope, concrete preparation.
StillSwitch prepares window information and layout before the shortcut is pressed. Preview capture is separate from selection, and its native interface avoids switching animation. These choices support responsiveness; they do not prove that a broader utility is slower or uses more memory. See the implementation priorities for the actual design.
Keeping window data local is not exclusive.
DockDoor says it has no analytics, usage tracking or crash reporters. StillSwitch contains no analytics either and keeps screen and window data on your Mac. License validation and update checks are separate network operations, described in its privacy explanation. Choose based on the interaction as well as the policy you are comfortable with. For version-specific source findings, including media lookups, read Screen Recording and preview privacy.
Choose the amount of integration you need.
Start with DockDoor if Dock previews, customization, open-source availability or support for an older Mac are important. Try StillSwitch if you want one focused change to Cmd+Tab on Apple Silicon with macOS 15 or later. Its 14-day trial lets you judge that routine in your own work before purchasing.
Use the two separately when evaluating keyboard behavior. More optional features can be valuable; fewer decisions can be valuable too. StillSwitch is built around the latter.
StillSwitch: 14 days free, then a paid license. No card for the trial. Apple Silicon and macOS 15 or later.