WINDOW SWITCHER COMPARISON

Manico vs StillSwitch: Choosing a Specific Mac Window

Choose an app first, or choose the window itself.

Written by the maker of StillSwitch. This article compares the Manico published at manico.mariuti.com. Official sources checked . Features and terms can change; this is not a hands-on speed test.

Both can reach individual windows.

Manico starts with an assigned app key and offers a picker for that app’s windows. StillSwitch puts eligible windows from different apps in one recent-use list. The useful question is whether you want to choose the app before choosing the document.

Manico: app key, then window choice.

Manico’s setup guide describes assigning a key to each app, invoking a customizable trigger—Control–Tab by default—and pressing the assigned key. Replacing the system Command–Tab is optional.

Its window-switching guide explains the next step: when the chosen app has multiple windows, a picker lets you select one with a letter, number, or arrow keys and Return. That picker is scoped to the selected app, rather than a combined list of every app’s windows.

For a routine centered on a few familiar apps, that separation can be useful. You choose the application you have in mind, then resolve which of its documents you need. Assigning and learning those keys is part of adopting that workflow.

StillSwitch: one list of the windows you used.

Imagine a draft in one browser window, a reference in another, and a PDF in Preview. StillSwitch gives each eligible window its own entry, ordered by recent use. The two browser windows are separate destinations alongside the PDF.

A quick press and release of Command–Tab returns to the previous eligible window. Hold Command after pressing Tab to see the list, advance with Tab, reverse with Shift, and release Command to select. The two-window toggle guide explains how returning between a draft and its reference works.

With Screen Recording permission, previews help you recognize the document’s appearance. Minimized windows use icons. StillSwitch does not add browser-tab search, app-key assignments or a per-app picker to this routine.

The interaction, layout and recent-use order are already decided. There are no themes, sizing controls or switching animations to tune. Initial macOS permissions and license activation are still separate steps. The goal is a small tool you can settle into without designing your own switcher.

Check the trial and the Mac requirements.

Manico’s official site lists US$15 once, including future updates, for Intel and Apple Silicon Macs on macOS 13 or later. It currently offers no free trial. Its terms provide a 14-day refund window after purchase and note that applicable tax may be added. A refund period is different from trying before paying.

StillSwitch requires Apple Silicon and macOS 15 or later. You can use the full app free for 14 days without a card or account. Continued use costs US$19.99 once for a StillSwitch 1.x license on up to three Macs, including 1.x updates. Future major versions are separate. See StillSwitch Pricing for purchase and activation details.

Manico’s privacy policy says its desktop app collects no personal information, usage data or analytics. StillSwitch also contains no app analytics; window data and previews remain local. Its licensing and update connections are explained in app privacy and security.

Which decision do you want to make?

If you usually think “open my editor, then choose its project,” Manico’s app-first route is worth considering. If you think “return to that draft” or recognize a reference by its preview, try StillSwitch’s combined window list.

Use your own documents to compare the two routines, with one switcher active at a time. Include an app with several windows and a return to your previous document. Notice which selection feels more natural, rather than assuming that fewer settings or a higher price proves better performance.

StillSwitch keeps window state and layout prepared while preview refreshes happen separately. That is the design described in Fast by design; it is not a measured speed advantage over Manico. Its appeal is the fixed, focused interaction.

Download for Mac StillSwitch setup, trial & requirements