WINDOW SWITCHER COMPARISON

WindowShelf vs StillSwitch: Organize Windows or Switch Back?

Keep your workspace in view, or call up a list only when you need it.

Written by the maker of StillSwitch. Official sources checked . This comparison covers documented features, not hands-on benchmarks. Offers and compatibility can change.

An organized sidebar or a momentary switcher?

WindowShelf is a candidate if you want windows organized in a sidebar, with workspace grouping and tiling. StillSwitch is for moving between individual windows on demand through Cmd+Tab. One gives your workspace an ongoing visible structure; the other focuses on getting you back to the next window with minimal decisions.

WindowShelf puts organization alongside your work.

The official WindowShelf window-switching page describes an app-grouped sidebar with window titles and active or minimized states. You can select windows with the mouse or keyboard.

Its main product page adds custom shelves for grouping windows across apps, sidebar-aware tiling and appearance options. The sidebar can remain visible or reveal from the screen edge, so it need not occupy the screen continuously. WindowShelf is listed as free for Intel and Apple Silicon Macs on macOS 13 or later.

Project structure and recent use answer different questions.

A project group answers, “Which windows belong to this task?” A recent-use list answers, “Which window was I working in?” Neither is a substitute for every use of the other.

If you keep several long-running projects open, explicitly grouping their windows may help you maintain context. If your work is mostly a conversation between a draft, a browser and a reference document, their recent use may already provide enough structure.

StillSwitch follows the latter approach. It keeps eligible individual windows in a common recent-use list, including separate windows from the same app. You do not create or maintain project shelves in StillSwitch.

There when you switch. Out of the way when you work.

StillSwitch appears on Cmd+Tab. Previews help you identify the window, Tab moves through the list, Shift reverses direction and releasing Command commits the selection. With the switch complete, your document becomes the focus again.

There is no sidebar placement, workspace taxonomy or layout style to configure. This is not an argument that a sidebar is wrong. It is a reason to choose StillSwitch when you want the smallest interaction between the work you are leaving and the work you are returning to.

Switching does not arrange your desktop.

StillSwitch does not tile windows or create a persistent project layout. If you need two documents visible together, use a window arrangement feature alongside it. Our window manager versus switcher guide explains that distinction.

Keeping arrangement outside the product lets StillSwitch make its own interaction more definite: one shortcut, a fixed presentation and no switching animation. You still have to grant the relevant macOS permissions; there is simply no interface-design exercise afterward.

Readiness matters more than extra controls.

StillSwitch prepares window state and layout ahead of time, while refreshing preview images separately. That is the basis of its responsiveness-focused design. We have not measured it against WindowShelf, and a sidebar’s presence alone says nothing about the performance of its implementation.

Choose a workspace tool or a switching habit.

Consider WindowShelf if project grouping, visible context or integrated tiling solves a real problem for you. Try StillSwitch if your desktop arrangement already works and all you want is a direct route back to the right window.

StillSwitch requires Apple Silicon and macOS 15 or later. Its 14-day trial is followed by a paid license. It contains no app analytics, and screen and window data stay local; license and update checks are the network exceptions.

Download for Mac StillSwitch setup, trial & requirements

StillSwitch: 14 days free, then a paid license. No card for the trial. Apple Silicon and macOS 15 or later.